Difference between revisions of "New Chains"
Jon Preddle (talk | contribs) |
John Lavalie (talk | contribs) |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
<span style="font-size:200%;">The Hartnell, Troughton and Pertwee Junkings - Take 5</span> | <span style="font-size:200%;">The Hartnell, Troughton and Pertwee Junkings - Take 5</span> | ||
− | {{TOC right}} | + | {{TOC right}}{{#css: table {width:100%;} }} |
Revision as of 03:38, 7 February 2017
The Hartnell, Troughton and Pertwee Junkings - Take 5
There are potentially dozens of different paths the film prints of the William Hartnell, Patrick Troughton and Jon Pertwee stories could have taken as they were bicycled from country to country over the years.
These tables summarise a fresh series of possible and potential distribution paths taken by groups of consecutive stories, using a scientific approach taking into account some of the available "film traffic" information, research into distribution methods (see Bicycling Chains Introduction) – with a smattering of educated guesswork! (The previous version of this page is here.)
(This is just our latest take (of several so far!) using the available information that's to hand – what is presented here could be hopelessly wrong, but it's been a fun exercise nevertheless.)
We have tried to keep each "chain" as simple as possible without resorting to the complicated exchange of different countries supplying different stories to different recipients; generally, the same grouping of consecutive stories would have been bicycled from the same provider to the same recipient, as opposed to stories being split up and sent to different recipients.
- For this latest iteration (#5, for those keeping track!), we have made some adjustments to the Stored Field Telerecordings (English) section. In the previous version, we hadn't taken into account that the replacement Stored Field telerecordings weren't created in strict story order, but in a seemingly random order; this could explain why the season one screenings in Mauritius were all over the place – they aired them in the order they received them. If we allow for 'out of order' distribution of eh Stored Fields from late 1967, the final country to air season one and two in English (Ethiopia) may have for season one at least been in a chain on its own.
- We've arranged each series of chains with the same "first country" as a separate table to make it easier to view
- Stations that had TIE Ltd as programme distributor probably did bicycle films solely within that network
- Notes relating to the "analysis" and thought process behind how these chains have been tabulated are at the bottom of this page and on the Bicycling Chains introduction page.
SEASONS ONE -- TWO
Suppressed Field Telerecordings
- All the season one and two stories (with the possible exception of one -– see note following) were telerecorded onto 16mm film using the Suppressed Field method. For some of these, the recordings were made during the actual live transmission on the BBC. For others, the copies were made some days later. (There is no clear pattern as to which stories / episodes were done "live" and which were filmed later; it was probably down to if and when the telerecording equipment was available.)
- The edited ex-New Zealand copies of The Time Meddler (S) that were returned from Nigeria were Stored Field telerecordings. The set of uncut prints of 1,2,3 found a few years later in the UK were also Stored Field and dates etched onto the films indicate they had been telerecorded during the actual live broadcast in July 1965. On that basis, we feel sure that the initial film recordings of that serial were made using that method, rather than the Suppressed Field method utilised for the rest of season two. (It's certain that The Chase was telerecorded as Suppressed then later as Stored, which places that serial as being the last one to be recorded by both methods.) But rather than placing S on its own, we have included it alongside all the other Suppressed Field serials in the tables, since the serial would have been supplied and bicycled at the same time as the others in the same batch
- The BBC held a complete set of prints of The Time Meddler in late 1976 but these were junked in 1977. The likely sources for those prints are Australia, Jamaica, Mauritius or Sierra Leone. Are these the same uncut UK-sourced Stored Field prints that were later recovered from a UK film collector and that exist today?
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Australia |
|
| |
Australia --- New Zealand | H---J---K---L |
|
|
Australia | Q---R---S |
|
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
New Zealand --- (Denmark) | A---B---C |
|
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Canada | A---B---C---D---E |
|
OR
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Canada --- Ghana | A---B---C---D---E |
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Singapore --- Hong Kong --- Thailand |
| ||
Singapore --- New Zealand --- (Iran) | D |
|
|
Singapore --- New Zealand | M---N---P---Q |
|
|
Singapore --- New Zealand --- Nigeria |
|
| |
Singapore |
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Gibraltar --- Aden --- Trinidad --- Bermuda --- Jamaica --- Barbados |
| ||
Gibraltar --- Aden --- Trinidad --- Jamaica --- Barbados |
| ||
Gibraltar --- Zambia |
|
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Rhodesia --- Zambia --- Uganda |
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Malta --- Cyprus | A---B---C |
| |
(Cyprus) --- Uganda | A---B---C | ||
Malta --- Cyprus --- Hong Kong --- Thailand | D---E |
| |
Malta --- Cyprus | F---G---H |
|
|
Malta | J---K---L |
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Nigeria --- Kenya --- Mauritius --- Sierra Leone |
| ||
Nigeria --- Kenya | |||
Nigeria |
|
- A Suppressed print of The Daleks part five was held at the BBC's film studios until late 1972 or early 1973 when it was "permanently borrowed" (along with a print of The Daleks' Master Plan part 2 (see below). If this was a print that had been returned from overseas, there are only a few "last in the chain" locations that it could have come from (Mauritius or Thailand?)
- It has been reported that an African TV station contacted the BBC in the mid-1990s asking what to do with episodes of Doctor Who. After establishing that what was held was from seasons one and two, the unhelpful receptionist told the caller that the episodes were not wanted and to destroy them. It's not known which country this was, but Nigeria and Ethiopia are two of the likely candidates. (In "Wiped!", Richard Molesworth offers that it was Nigeria.)
Stored Field Telerecordings (Dubbed)
- In early 1966, the BBC offered a selection of season one and two Doctor Who serials to Spanish-speaking countries. It commissioned dialogue-free Music / Effects only audio tracks, which were created by mid-1966 by Eddie Montague (who is interviewed here). And to create new prints without the English soundtracks the BBC struck fresh telerecordings using the superior Stored Field method. A smaller package of the same episodes was later supplied to Arabic countries
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Venezuela --- Chile --- (Dominican Republic?) --- Costa Rica |
|
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Mexico |
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Tunisia --- Iran |
|
| |
Iran |
|
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Morocco --- Algeria |
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Saudi Arabia --- Jordan --- Libya |
|
Stored Field Telerecordings (English)
- At the same time that the new "non-English" telerecordings were being made (see above), the BBC took the opportunity to replace all of their old Suppressed Field telerecordings of the season one and two serials with newly struck Stored Field telerecordings. (As noted above, The Time Meddler was only ever done as Stored Field, in July 1965.) Some stories had a second "new" negative but without an optical or magnetic soundtrack -- i.e. a mute print -- struck in 1967, 1968 or 1969 (which may have been done in preparation for mixing in "Music / Effects" tracks for potential sales to Spanish and / or Arabic speaking countries, which ultimately never eventuated). (Some of the season three serials which already existed as Stored Field recordings also had backup negatives made; The War Machines had a "2nd neg" created in May 1968.)
- If the new Stored prints were introduced into the bicycling system around August 1967, it's unlikely that the Suppressed prints already being used within an established chain were intercepted and replaced with Stored prints while still in transit between countries. Therefore, only those countries at the start of a chain receiving a set package of stories would have received the new Stored prints. The only chains where that would be the case are the Caribbean chain (but only with a partial set), and Africa (which was the only "new" chain to potentially receive a full set)
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Mauritius --- Sierra Leone |
|
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Barbados --- Jamaica --- Ethiopia |
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Barbados --- Jamaica --- Ethiopia --- Nigeria |
|
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Barbados --- Jamaica |
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Ethiopia |
|
- Some of the prints of The Web Planet (N) returned from Nigeria still had the BBC's VT clock on the leader; this does suggest they were supplied directly by the BBC in 1973 (perhaps as Audition prints?) since the majority of prints sent overseas had the VT clock strip removed and replaced with a fresh leader by one of the broadcasters. That these prints retained the clock and not a leader from another broadcaster does strongly suggest that they were not copies that had been bicycled into Nigeria from another country. (But if they had been bicycled from elsewhere, then Ethiopia would be the likely source, as shown in the above table.)
SEASONS THREE -- FOUR -- FIVE -- SIX
- All the serials from these four seasons were telerecorded using the superior Stored Field method during their BBC transmission
- Prints of Mission to the Unknown and The Daleks' Master Plan were despatched to Australia in early 1966 along with the first couple of serials from Season 3. It's doubtful that the BBC would have pre-struck another set of prints intended for a subsequent sale so early on, especially without the confirmed first sale from Australia. And with the censorship issues in Australia arising in September 1966, and the subsequent arrangement with Terry Nation to withdraw all Dalek serials around that same time, again it's doubtful that the BBC would have struck any additional prints until both issues had been satisfactorily resolved. (As it transpired, the censorship problems did not get resolved at all, but the block on sales of Dalek stories was lifted by the end of 1967, by which time it was too late (and therefore too expensive!) to sell The Daleks' Master Plan to anywhere else as part of the Season 3 package.)
- A print of The Daleks' Master Plan episode 2 was held at the BBC's film studios until late 1972 or early 1973 when it was "permanently borrowed". The BBC also still held prints of episodes 3 and 4 at that time, and episodes 5 and 10 turned up in 1983. (These may well have been the Australian prints, assuming the episodes had been returned to the BBC soon after it had been "rejected" by the ABC in mid-1967.)
- The BBC still had a complete set of prints of The Tenth Planet in 1973. Part 4 "disappeared" soon after it had been borrowed by Blue Peter, with only the other three still held in 1976. Unlike the case with Mission to the Unknown and The Daleks' Master Plan above, it's possible that this set of prints was struck to be included in the package of episodes sold to Barbados in mid-1967. But because The Power of the Daleks had been withdrawn from sale in 1966, The Tenth Planet was probably also pulled from sale and the "unsold" Barbados prints held "on the shelf" until such time as the restriction on Daleks was removed. When The Tenth Planet was re-issued for sale again in 1968 and sold to New Zealand, the BBC may have overlooked that it had a set prepared earlier (see what we did there?!) and sent a fresh set to NZ
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Australia | T---T/A---U---V---W---X---Y---AA---BB---
CC---DD---EE---FF---GG---HH---JJ---KK---LL--- |
|
|
Australia --- Singapore | Z |
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Barbados --- Zambia --- Sierra Leone | T---U---W---X---Y---Z---AA---BB---CC |
|
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
New Zealand --- Singapore | T---U---W---X---Y---AA---CC---DD---EE |
| |
New Zealand --- Singapore --- Nigeria | BB |
|
|
New Zealand | LL---MM---NN---OO---PP---QQ---RR---SS |
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Germany |
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Uganda --- New Zealand | FF---GG---HH---JJ---KK |
|
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Singapore --- Hong Kong --- Zambia | FF---GG---HH---JJ---KK |
|
|
(Hong Kong) --- Singapore --- Hong Kong | MM | ||
Hong Kong --- Singapore |
| ||
Hong Kong --- Singapore --- Nigeria |
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Gibraltar |
| ||
Gibraltar --- Zambia |
|
- Three different prints exist for part 5 of The Dominators: one came back from Australia in 1975 (it has the Australian censor edits, and is the one that was reissued for broadcast in 1984 and used for the 1990 VHS release); one was held by a film collector as early as 1973 or 1974 (so was probably returned from Gibraltar); and another was given to the BFI in 1977 (so is probably the one that had been bicycled to Nigeria). The tables here account for three copies across three chains -- so if all the known prints of one of the episodes struck for one serial sold to the same countries were returned to the BBC and can be accounted for, then it's logical to assume that all the other serials sold to the same set of countries would have been returned to the BBC at the same time…
SEASONS SEVEN -- EIGHT -- NINE -- TEN -- ELEVEN
- All the serials from these five seasons were telerecorded as 16mm black and white prints using the superior Stored Field method
- Gibraltar received AAA, BBB and CCC at the same time as UU through ZZ, which probably came from the same source: Hong Kong / Singapore
- A damaged print of an episode of CCC exists, but the origin of this print is unknown
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Australia --- New Zealand |
|
||
Australia --- Bangladesh |
| ||
Australia |
|
| |
Australia --- Gibraltar |
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Hong Kong --- Singapore --- Gibraltar |
| ||
Singapore --- Hong Kong --- Gibraltar |
|
Countries in Bicycling Group | Group of Stories | Proven Final Fate/s | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Lebanon --- Saudi Arabia --- Qatar? |
| ||
Lebanon --- Saudi Arabia --- Bangladesh |
| ||
Saudi Arabia |
| ||
Saudi Arabia --- Lebanon |
| ||
Saudi Arabia --- Bangladesh |
| ||
Saudi Arabia --- Qatar? |
|
- As noted on the 1974 Recall page, a batch of episodes was returned to the BBC in 1981/1982, and despite the "do not destroy" order on them, they were junked. It's possible that those returns were Pertwees from the Middle East, since the screenings of the b/w Pertwees had concluded by 1979 and were not part of the 1974 recall.
General Summary
WILLIAM HARTNELL STORIES
Keeping the bicycling routes as simple as possible, if we assume that country X generally always supplied country Y with its prints, then:
- Australia – always had its own prints, and returned all but a few to the BBC in 1975
- Countries in West Africa (Nigeria, Ghana and Sierra Leone) and those in East Africa (Rhodesia, Zambia, Mauritius and Ethiopia) likely shared prints from time to time; of note, Nigeria acquired The War Machines from Singapore and The Time Meddler from New Zealand in 1973; Sierra Leone still had its prints of both serials at that time (they weren't returned to the BBC until 1974), so it does raise the question as to why Nigeria didn't source those two serials from closer to home! (One likely answer is that the BBC didn't want to split up Sierra Leone's holdings, as it may have planned to further sell those episodes as a complete set elsewhere; the Singapore and NZ prints were already from broken sets and therefore could be sent to Nigeria.)
- The New Zealand censors classified the season three episodes between May and July 1968, which was before or during the broadcasts in Barbados and Zambia, so New Zealand's prints cannot have been sourced from either of those countries
- It's a matter of recorded fact that New Zealand sent its prints to Singapore in 1972; since New Zealand did not have The Gunfighters, Singapore's prints of that must have been supplied from elsewhere else (Australia?) or from the BBC
PATRICK TROUGHTON STORIES
Keeping the bicycling routes as simple as possible, if we assume that country X generally always supplied country Y with its prints, even after an interim period of several years, then:
- Australia – always had its own prints, and returned all but a few to the BBC in 1975
- New Zealand – bicycled in as well as acquired fresh sets of prints. It had disposed of most of its prints by the end of 1974
- Hong Kong and Singapore always shared prints; a number of them may have ended up in Africa; in fact, it does appear that it was deliberate that the "Asian" prints eventually made their way to Africa and/or Gibraltar, bringing them closer to 'home' for the inevitable "recall" to London
- The BBC may have automatically struck prints of the season six stories for New Zealand, but when these were not purchased by the NZBC, they were sent to Gibraltar instead, which may explain why Gibraltar got those episodes before it got season five
JON PERTWEE STORIES
Keeping the bicycling routes as simple as possible, if we assume that country X generally always supplied country Y with its prints, even after an interim period of several years, then:
- Australia – always had its own prints, and likely returned all but a few to the BBC by 1975, when colour broadcasts commenced
- Hong Kong and Singapore always shared prints
- The BBC may have automatically struck prints of the season seven stories for New Zealand, but when these were not purchased, they were sent to Gibraltar instead
NOTES
- [1] – Barbados and Zambia either shared the same prints OR, they had their own set of prints. (There's also the important factor that Barbados had TIE Ltd as its programme supplier, but Zambia was not part of that network.) There is a window of only three to four months between the airdates in Barbados and Zambia, but Zambia could well have received its prints before Barbados, but scheduled the serials to screen much later.
- If the former, Zambia either got its prints of the season three stories directly from the BBC (in which case the films would have been sent the "long way" around the southern cape of Africa since the Suez Canal was closed at the time), or they were bicycled in several shipments from Barbados; the shipping distances from either point of origin to Zambia is roughly the same, although it's likely that the films were sent to London or via another mid-way point first (via Gibraltar?) rather than directly between Barbados and Zambia
- If the latter, then the Caribbean prints may have been retained in case Jamaica or Trinidad picked up the series later on, which clearly did not happen. Why? It's a "chicken or egg" scenario: did the films go from Barbados to Zambia because Jamaica and Trinidad did not want them, or did Jamaica and Trinidad miss out because the films had been sent to Zambia? There is only a gap of a year between Barbados screening season three and when Jamaica aired season two. If Barbados kept the prints, why didn't Jamaica carry on after season two? Or was it simply a matter that both Jamaica and Trinidad rejected the offer of more episodes, leaving Barbados free to bicycle the films to Africa instead? For this reason alone, we believe the prints were no longer in the Caribbean by the time Jamaica caught up and wanted more, hence we've grouped Barbados and Zambia in the same chain for season three only
- [2] – It seems very likely that the majority of the stray Patrick Troughton episodes kept by the BBC and those that were later recovered from UK film collectors were all from the same sources: mostly from Gibraltar, Zambia and Australia, and some from Singapore. The prints of the Jon Pertwee serials up to the end of season 9 held by the BBC at the end of 1976 may have also been returns from Gibraltar, since that run of episodes had concluded in late 1974, and Gibraltar was the final Commonwealth country to air them; it would seem that the BBC deliberately sold and therefore carefully channelled the films through the various countries in Asia, the Caribbean and Africa so they would end up in Gibraltar so they could be returned to "near-by" London at a much lower cost. (Were these returned at the same time in the 1974 "recall" of the first two Doctors?) Gibraltar certainly has form for returning material to the BBC soon after broadcast as late as 1978 (being geographically 'close' to London makes returning films a matter of convenience over storing the films awaiting the inevitable "return" instructions that'll come anyway), so it's safe to accept that it did so consistently and regularly. The b/w prints of the three serials that didn't air – DDD, FFF, JJJ - may well have been struck and intended for the Hong Kong / Singapore set, but left unsold "on the shelf".
- Since the BBC retained the original telerecording negative for many episodes but did not necessarily also hold a positive print for each, with various prints being returned from overseas on a regular basis, they may have taken the opportunity to retain any print for which they also had the negative -- and to use that returned copy as a viewing print -- and discard all of those for which they did not also have a negative. (For instance, the BBC retained the original Stored Field telerecording negative for The Crusade part three. In 1976 they also held a Stored print of the same episode; that print may have been struck directly from the negative for the purpose of having a viewing copy on file (which means it was paid for by Enterprises), or the BBC deliberately preserved that print when it arrived from overseas for the purpose of having a viewing print on file. If it is the latter scenario, there are -- per this table at least -- only two possible overseas sources for this print.)
- [3] – Since Australia, Gibraltar and Hong Kong / Singapore had presumably returned all retained prints to the BBC by 1975, and these three stories (XX, YY, ZZ) were sent to Zambia in 1976, what was despatched to ZTV may well have been a miss-matched selection of film prints from these countries, including some of the ex-ABC films with censor cuts.
- For comparison, the original Bicycling Chains table is HERE